Not Legal? No Lawyer! Is that about to change?

“A 4-year-old boy from Honduras approached a police officer in Anzaldulas Park earlier this year after crossing the Rio Grande from Mexico in Mission. Child welfare advocates have predicted the number of unaccompanied children entering the U.S. could reach 60,000 this year, attributing the influx primarily to a growing “humanitarian crisis” caused by rampant gang and cartel violence in Central and South America. Photo by Johnny Hanson/Houston Chronicle”

MSN News’ article states that, “Rep. Zoe Lofgren of California knew what would happen as hundreds of thousands of children fled to the United States on their own over the last few years.

Because being present in the U.S. illegally is a civil offense, there is no right to an attorney during immigration or asylum proceedings. That means many children stand alone before an immigration judge when they ask to stay in this country.

Lofgren said it’s a problem she has fought for years. In the 1970s, she practiced immigration law and taught at the Santa Clara University School of Law. She knew that many who came fleeing violence would be sent back home because they lacked legal representation and had no one to advocate for them.

Now the San Jose Democrat and 54 of her House colleagues have put forth a bill to argue that, at a minimum, children and people with certain disabilities should have government-appointed attorneys to help them navigate the asylum process. The bill has been referred to the House Judiciary Committee, where Lofgren is the highest-ranking Democrat on the Subcommittee on Immigration and Border Security.

“You’ve got a 10-year-old who speaks Spanish, and they’re in a courtroom facing a trained prosecutor making the asylum case. It’s not going to work,” Lofgren said in an interview in her Capitol Hill office. “The consequences of being unable to make your case are severe.”

Since October 2013, more than 132,000 Central American children and teens without legal status have been caught near the U.S.-Mexico border, according to U.S. Customs and Border Protection. It isn’t yet clear whether that trend will continue this year, or if federal deportation efforts have caused it to slow.

A child who goes before an immigration judge without an attorney has a 1 in 10 chance of being allowed to stay, while about half of children with an attorney get U.S. protection, according to a study by the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse at Syracuse University. About half of unaccompanied children get an attorney, the analysis shows.

Although being in the country illegally is a civil offense, being caught crossing the border can lead to federal criminal charges.

Opponents of the bill argue that American taxpayers shouldn’t pay for an attorney to represent a person who came to the country illegally. Jon Feere, legal policy analyst for the conservative Center for Immigration Studies, wrote in a March 15 blog post on the center’s website that if immigration groups want an attorney for people in the U.S. illegally, being in the country without legal status should be made a criminal offense, not a civil one.

“It can be a difficult situation for children, no doubt, and it’s unfortunate that the parents have put them in that situation. And it’s unfortunate that the Obama administration has encouraged people to risk their lives crossing the border, but that is precisely what Deferred Action has done,” Feere said. “There’s already a way to make sure all illegal aliens receive an attorney during their immigration proceedings: criminalize immigration law.”

Lofgren said concerns about cost shouldn’t trump due process. She argued that providing access to attorneys could help avoid delays and streamline the process, which would save money. Several nonprofit groups provide free legal representation to migrant children, as does a Justice Department program, though many still end up in court without an advocate.

Many immigration judges delay and postpone hearings as they look for an attorney to represent children seeking asylum, Lofgren said.

“Not having a lawyer gums up the works,” she said. “That costs money and time. You translate those delays and the cost with those delays over 50,000 cases, it’s a lot of money.”

When a child is detained, Department of Homeland Security asylum officers perform an initial screening to determine whether the child may have a valid claim for asylum and should go before an immigration judge.

“These kids, most of them, over 90 percent, were found to have valid claims by the trained asylum officer. But of course if they weren’t represented, they were unable to actually articulate that when it came to court,” Lofgren said.

Whether the government must provide attorneys for children and people with special needs is a question pending in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington. The American Civil Liberties Union and immigrant rights groups want to require the government to provide appointed counsel for every child who cannot afford a lawyer in immigration court proceedings. The Justice Department is contesting the lawsuit.

In a recently unsealed deposition, Judge Jack Weil, an assistant chief immigration judge for the Justice Department, made the case that migrant children as young as 3 are capable of representing themselves in deportation hearings. Weil’s job includes coordinating training for other immigration judges and court staff.

“I’ve taught immigration law literally to 3-year-olds and 4-year-olds. It takes a lot of time. It takes a lot of patience,” Weil said. “They get it. It’s not the most efficient, but it can be done.”

Lofgren said the statement was absurd.

“If you are a mother, it’s hard to say how it’s fair that a small child should be left on their own in an important proceeding,” she said. “There’s no other area of the law where that happens.”

A group of immigration lawyers made the same point recently in a video in which they asked children questions that they would hear in court.

Lofgren understands her bill may not move far…


“We have a moral obligation to ensure these children and other vulnerable populations seeking our nation’s protection receive due process, and are not merely deported back to the dangers and the terrors they risked so much to escape,” she said.

Lofgren says she sees her own kids, now grown, in the faces of children who came to the U.S. alone.

“When they were 5 they could not have gone into court, faced off with a trained prosecutor and made a coherent case for asylum in a language they didn’t speak,” she said.”

But this is not a new phenonmenon…

According to, “An unaccompanied child migrant was the first person in line on opening day of the new immigration station at Ellis Island. Her name was Annie Moore, and that day, January 1, 1892, happened to be her 15th birthday. She had traveled with her two little brothers from Cork County, Ireland, and when they walked off the gangplank, she was awarded a certificate and a $10 gold coin for being the first to register. Today, a statue of Annie stands on the island, a testament to the courage of millions of children who passed through those same doors, often traveling without an older family member to help them along.”


These standards do not hold true in Boone County in Juvenile Abuse/Neglect proceedings. All children, regardless of their immigration status, receive a GAL appointment. In fact, our program often does not know if the child/family is here legally or not. Those questions just are not as important as, “Has this child seen a doctor recently?” and “Has the child been fed and clothed regularly?” Each child is assigned a case number, a CASA advocate/GAL, and receives the services provided by a case worker. If needed, a bilingual worker and (we try!) a bilingual CASA will be working the case. If a bilingual CASA is not available, then someone serves as a translator for the advocate.

A trend we are aware of is children who are citizens by birth but have undocumented parents. This can make for very complicated issues within the family, especially if a parent is facing deportation. To see how this can effect a family (and the child welfare system) check out the video below.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s